Tavis Smiley's Haterology on Barack Obama
Please Subscribe to YourBlackWorld.com!
By Dr. Boyce Watkins
www.BoyceWatkins.com
I couldn't help but notice that while many of us have been carried away by the Barack Obama train, some have refused to buy a ticket. I understand completely, because I am the last person to buy anyone's hype. Healthy skepticism is a good thing, and we should all keep it in our pocket.
But haterology is a serious science and diagnosing it can be an art.
My latest patient is Mr. Tavis Smiley. I like Tavis as a person and respect him a great deal. Tavis Smiley has branded himself as one of the top black leaders in America and is right up there with Marc Lamont Hill as one of my most respected colleagues.
While my respect for Brother Smiley runs deep, I know he is also human. In our humanity, one must be realistic when considering the fact that Tavis understands that his business is a business. There is a marketing philosophy that must be implemented, some degree of competition and ultimately, some lines that must be drawn in the sand. After all, there is more than one Tavis Smiley out there, and his work with The Tom Joyner Morning Show (among others) has allowed him to separate himself from the pack. Brother Smiley's success, prominence and power were planned, it didn't just happen by accident.
Barack Obama, by announcing his candidacy for the White House DURING Tavis Smiley's State of the Black Union was, to some, a serious line being drawn. I am sure Brother Smiley felt that anyone who is anyone in the black community must be part of his conference. Barack Obama didn't feel that way, and seemed to be less than willing to pledge allegiance to existing Black Leadership.
Tavis Smiley's State of The Black Union conference, along with his work on The Tom Joyner Morning Show and his Covenant with Black America have done a great deal for the black community. However, they have done far more for Tavis Smiley's book sales and power within the community. I can't hate on that. After all, I am a Finance Professor, so I fully understand how capitalism works. Also, my work in media allows me to understand that you're nobody until you convince somebody that you're somebody. It's not what you know, it's.....well, you get the point.
Simultaneously, Tavis Smiley must work through the demons within him that have always christened himself as the next Barack Obama. Shit, I'm sure Tavis Smiley thought he would be Barack Obama before Barack Obama thought he would be Barack Obama. So, it must be incredibly confusing for Smiley to watch Obama go from "just some guy" to the next JFK. Tavis Smiley, Al Sharpton and others have, quite honestly, been humbled. Brothers like Tavis Smiley and Al Sharpton don't like being humbled.
Smiley's tone of "putting people on blast" for not attending his conference is somewhat problematic and reminds me of an area of Finance called Agency Theory. Agency Theory always questions the incentives of the manager or protector and allows you to wonder if the leader is doing what is best for his constituency or himself. Tavis Smiley's decision to "put people on blast" begs larger, more relevant questions: Are you being careful to balance your personal agenda with the broader needs of the community? You, Brother Smiley, sacrifice a great deal for black people, but are you willing to also sacrifice your personal power? If Barack Obama were serving your interests a bit more, would you have a different disposition?
In layman's terms, this sacrifice is like asking a man to allow another man to sleep with his girlfriend if he clearly knows that the other man would make her happier. Only true love would make a man say "yes" to such a request. Similarly, only true love for the black community can lead Tavis Smiley, or anyone else, to give up their own black power to open the gates for someone who might be a bit more effective. I am not sure if Obama is that guy, but alot of people think he is.
I am not assuming that Tavis Smiley's intentions are not honorable. But I am certainly assuming that he himself struggles with this issue, as we all do at some point. Again, it's about being human. Would a bad mother give up her child to a good one? Would a star athlete sit on the bench if it will help the team win?
The same questions can be asked of many other power brokers in the black community, all of whom have been somewhat undermined by Obama's sudden rise to prominence. Obama owes no one, he has a new team and he refuses to be beholden to the Civil Rights Movement. He is like Al Capone coming to Chicago to run the liquor business "the right way". Such boldness makes the haters come out of the wood work. That's a fact.
Obama is benefiting from a landslide of black support, built on social credit being extended on campaign promises. The Black Community is like the loving, committed spouse, willing to ignore immediate needs so their partner can conquer the world. But at the end of the day, something must be delivered.
Smiley understands this and that is why I believe he works hard for black people. At the same time, Tavis must remember the wise words of Spiderman's Uncle: With great power comes great responsibility.
Translation: Tavis - please make sure your attacks on Obama are about the community and not about you. Most of us can't quite tell the difference.
Please join the premier black news site in America by signing up below. It's FREE!
Please click the logo if you wish to go directly to the site without signing up.
Your Black World is a black news site that focuses on
presenting black news in a way that celebrates our diversity. We feature
the top academics in America, along with black celebrity news, black educational
news, black relationships, black sports, black health, black women's issues,
black politics, etc.
We have over 20 black blogs and a slew of top notch writers,
as well as video, information and a whole lot of black love.
In Your Black World, there is no ONE WAY to be black.
Being black is a state of mind, and all perspectives are respected. From
Flavor Flav to Oprah Winfrey, ALL Black News is Here!
posted by Boyce Watkins at
6:45 AM
133 Comments:
That was awesome. I fully agree with your commentary.
If Tavis is strictly asking for clarification on ISSUES that affect Black America, I am in total agreement with him to press it on ALL candidates not just Obama. If the S.C. debate would have talked about issues dealing with Black America instead of Ali v. Frazier attacks, then our issues could have been addressed at the debate instead of having him ask him and other candidates (which Clinton has accepted) to be apart of it.
What is craziest is that you have NEVER seen Tavis go off on a white candidate like this before. If this were consistent, it would be ok. The problem is that he is pushing Obama harder than he has ever pushed anyone else.
This commentary was "spot on." You carefully stated the issue, analyzed it and left it for us to make our final decision.
Finally, someone has taken Tavis to task in a way that makes sense. This is not hating. This is a simple analysis of the facts laced with opinion and commentary.
I TOTALLY agree with your commentary. Honesty can sting and flat out hurt at times but, we all need a dose of it every now and then.
Thank you my brother. As passionate as Mr. Smiley may be, I think he can be somewhat self-righteous at times with his efforts to “hold people accountable.” He is not but A voice for Black America…not The voice.
I also agree that your comment is awesome. I fully agree with your commentary.
I also thought the same thing as far as Tavis being on an ego-trip. Tavis is a great man and write great books and he as a person means a lot to the African American community, however, there comes a time when we all have to look at ourselves in the mirror. Tavis, if you take a good look you will see that you and Obama are alike in more ways than few. Although, we don't find many black men on such a high level of understanding, however the two of you stands out. Let's just all get alone--smiling.
Tavis is wrong to do what he is doing. That's like a little kid getting mad because his mother is the Attorney General working on a big case, but won't take more time off to help him with her homework. The child can wait a few days and let the mother focus on putting food on the table.
The child's needs still matter, and the mother will get to them. But the child cannot be selfish in his need for attention.
Tavis is being childish!
Tavis put the republican nominees McCain, Romney, Guliani) on blast for not showing up at a convention.
Why not Obama? I even saw him on Jay Leno discussing it! He is though, drawing attention to himself by not letting it go after he put him on blast.... Calm down Tavis!!!
Tavis needs to understand that although Barack is not able to attend the State of the Black Union Address, he is attempting to become a Black man giving the State of the Union Address!
Tavis needs to take his "Big Boy Pill" and get over himself. There is room for two successful black men in the arena. Why must we always fight against ourselves. Lets get behind Obama and show love and support, not hate and envy. We have to much work to do and we need hundreds of black leaders and role models, not just one.
Thank you so much for speaking to the issue and putting all of us "on blast." It bothers me tremendously that we Blacks allow White America (especially the white press & politicians and ego tripping blacks - yes like Mr. Smiley to define who our leaders are & to whom we "should" be beholden. I personally have no problems with Jesse, Al, Tavis .etc - but I do not consider any of them my leader. It is interesting that when anything happens "black" in America - principally the white media interviews "their" chosen blacks and immediately that somehow becomes the black view from the black leader. As to the issue at hand - run Obama - run - run away from the haters - - run away from the "underminders". Be yourself and know that some blacks are not "hero-worshipping you" but we are immensley proud of you - and in the vernacular of "Forrest Gump" - run until the shackles of envy, jealousy, and hatred fall by the wayside.
As usual, Boyce gives us another logical point of view, but I don't completely agree. I think Tavis is right and Obama needs to show up, especially if Hillary is showing up. It can't just come down to it being no big deal for Hillary to be there because her husband can campaign for her, but Barack has to do it on his own. I don't recall seeing any specific issues Obama has addressed regarding the black community's needs. He's done a great job addressing issues that affect the nation, but nothing specific to blacks. And we do have our own issues. I think it's time for him to talk about them. If he just flew in for a few hours, it would be worth it. And, I'm a supporter of his, having worked his campaign and housed some of his campaign workers in my home when they came to my town for the elections.
True,
Hello Tavis,
Obama is running for President of America, Not Minority "Black America"
Calm your Ego Smiley because your "Talking" won't do much to change Black America. A Black Spiritual and Religious revolution, like the Jews,is what is needed Bro. Black America is "All Talked Out"
Who made Obama a black man anyway??
For a man with-seemingly-so much education, Tavis needs to "get a girp." Who does he think he is? I agree with another bloger who stated that he is harder Obama than he is on any white canidate! I remember last year when Fred Thompson was invited to a black forum, he did not attend, which he had the right NOT to do, but there was not anything said by Tavis about that, at least not that I heard about?
With a family and schedule as hectic and full as Obama's, I can see why he would not be able to attend. Not because he is not "black enough," or dosen't care about the issues Black Americans' face, but because the man is busy!
Tavis must realize that the State of Black America is not the only place for a person of color to express their blackness. That's just crazy
I agree with your commentary. Tavis whom I used to respect a great deal has gotten so full of himself that he is forgetting the very things that he once embodied and speaks on his book. In the words of Bill Cosby Come on People!
Come on Tavis! this man is running for President of the United States, he won't get there with the Black Vote alone. Barack would not be that naive to think he can win the presidency with Blacks helping to put him there and not address the issues that affect us. What has occurred is shift among blacks where we no longer let others decide who our leaders are i.e Clinton slave mentality. Tavis we love you and appreciate what you do for our community but you have gotten caught up brother! now it's time to catch up!
Can someone tell me why Tavis is SO LATE on asking for his townhall on the Covenant of Black America? He is asking the candidates to participate in New Orleans, LA. Why didn't he have this slated before the Louisiana Primary? It would have made more sense to kill two birds with one stone: address our isses & get the candidates to participate. Who is planning his platform? I know black people have a reputation of being late, but Tavis this is ridiculous.
I am in agreement with the commentary. I, too, listen to Tavis from time to time on the Tom Joyner Morning Show. I find him to be a hard working, insightful and intelligent commentator committed to the betterment of black people. However, at this juncture, I am wondering if he was positioning himself to be heir apparent as leader of black people's platform and considers Obama to be an obstructionist to his plan.
I hope that a close friend or mentor of Tavis will get him to reflect on the 'stategy' necessary for anyone to win a majority vote to be president in this country at this time. Perhaps then, he will understand the difference between the Primaries and the Presidential Candidates and the difference between handouts from a benevolent benefactor (Clinton) and entitlements based on citizenship classification and service performed in all sectors of our society (Obama).
You can clearly see who the Clintons think you need to target to get elected. They have effectively removed themselves from the 'honorary' designation of first black president and family by Bill's 'racist' remarks and Hillary's condescending and dismissive behaviors.
Keep up the good work. This site has some of the best commentary I have read on this subject.
I respect and admire the talents of Tavis. It is bewildering to witness his back-biting, mean-spirited,nasty criticism of our man Obama.
Hillary is still recovering after being trampled by Obama in, DC, MD, and VA and is desperate to appear on the"Tavis Smiley" show. That's really what it amounts to. Obama has gained political momentum and respect in a way not seen. We must continue to support him as he faces campaign challenges.
As the church mothers use to say, "ain't no love on board".
We need to pray for Tavis.
I am a bit confused as to how Tavis thought his agenda is larger and more important than an African American campaigning to become President. After all wouldn't that be the pinnacle of his plight?Tavis has become arrogant and feels like his word is gospel in the community. This is a classic crab in the bucket example and Willie Lynch philosophy in action. I am no longer a fan of Tavis Smiley..after all he has become rich off the African American community.
It is important to remember that Obama is not running to become the President of black America. He is running to become the President of the United States of America. This moment represents a paradigm shift in the history of this country which has implications that are global in nature. People all over the world are celebrating and looking forward to a differnt kind of future because of what is about to happen. Truth is no one anticipated it and some people are having a hard time adapting. This is cosmic. Barrack Obama is destined to open a new Era for all people. I am extremely exited to be a witness to it. Lets all settle down and prepare to become more than we ever imagined we can be. Much love to Tavis who I adore for his dedication to his people. He his human and therefore fallible, but I believe his heart is in the right place. Remember, love first, even if we disagree sometimes. For specifics on Obama concerning black issues or any other issue go to his campaign website. The issues that affect black people are socio-economic and the solutions are therefore relevent to all oppressed people.
I am thoroughly disgusted with Travis....doesn't he know he's not the most important thing around..Obama is working hard trying to get nominated, he's probably not even sleeping much and under constant stress..just to have to hear some BS from Mr. Hater of the Year Travis. You're not all of that Travis...so go and regroup, please.
Interesting commentary.
1. The agency theory perspective is useful, and can be applied to any of the candidates.
2. "Hate" has, this year, become the default ascribed motive of choice for all who oppose a supporter's candidate. That says a lot about where the country is -- and how easy it's going to be for whoever wins the election to govern it.
I wholeheartedly didagree with your comment.
A person has a right to be a thinker, draw their own conclusions and not get caught up in the hype of proposed nationalism because fo a person's skin color.
I too, agree with Brothe Tavis and have not gotten on the Obama train.
Remember, my brothers and sisters that we are free from slavery now and can READ, LISTEN STUDY and FACT FIND for ourselves.
If you would read and study the "candidates" voting record and truly follow his plagarized speeches he makes from MLK, RFK, JFK and Reagen (often unattributed) you too would get off the train.
Be not deceived my sisters and brothers. It has happened too often to us before and we have believed the hype, drank the Kool-Aid from "so-called" leaders and perished.
We are too bright a people to get caught up in rhetoric.
Once you read and study, I ask the question, "Will you remain inspired?" I think not.
A lifelong, informed, registered Democrat from the State of Missouri
hi tavis
stick to your guns iam with you all the way iam voting for hillary and please note that iam a 56 yr old black woman and i live in georgia our blacks are so confuse and they are on a bandwagon from our radio stations that needs to stop pushing up problems .what they dont know is that superdelegates been aroung 100 yrs and today we have become so concern about this election for only 2 reasons 1 black candidate and 1 white female but 100 yrs ago it didnt matter about who was president what they are doing now is out of control
Tavis Smiley is an intelligent, thinking, pro-Black individual.
Are we to abandon him as we have abandoned the Clinton machine that carried so many of us from poverty to middle class and from middle class to affluence?
Are we so shallow that when we get where we want to be that we jump ship and get on the first "train" smoking to the "rhetorical promise land"?
When I ask you why Obama you say he inspires me. Get inspired by Jesus, Allah, your inner self's your Mothers and Fathers.
Vote informed and intelligently and do not bet on black when black has never done anything for you from East St Louis, IL to Chicago from the perch of his 1.6 million dollar mansion that he purchased in an illigel, shady deal with a crook.
Black people, black people, study to show thyself approved and get the facts.
Obama is not for you unless you make more than $75,000.00 a year and even then he does not have a plan for carrying anything through.
Especially when he does not even show up to vote when he was in Illinois ir now in the Senate.
Wake up my people.
Dr.Boyce was on point, and my question to Tavis would be? How many time has a group asked you to come to help with their program and you was not able to make it because of work?? As an individual who has his master in education,and depth in black history I have one question to ask Mr.Smiley? do you remember how and why the Black power movement began, the need for change in the way that black people were looked at? understanding that in order to make a change you must be will to take a new road, because they are waiting for you on that old one and know when,were, and how to stop you. Tavis we support you in what you do, we watch your show on PBS, and yes hie wife can answer yor questions. Its time tomove forward in this nation and after Dr.King if you checkmout what Obama has done,I think that you will find that at an young age Obama has also dne many thing that people could not forsee. It time for us let the past be the past. When the white man tell you that he is not to be held for what their forfather did, we we sasy ok. This is an movement that my NEVER come again,so as the OJAY'S sing in the song Love Train,everyboby get on board.
All African Americans should BOYCOTT Smiley's State of the Union in New Orleans.
If Obama can not talk about being Black and issues concerning Black people now what makes us think that he will once inside the White House?
Tavis is not hating Obama, Tavis is loving Black.
There is a difference.
Thank you for the commentary i agrre whole heartedly.I always felt that we have so much self hate that we deliberately search for the negative first in a brother or sister instead of the positive. Negative thinking is a dangerous course for anybody as well as kill the soul. Obama is not the savior for Black people and if he is elected to the White house i hope we don't have outrageous expectation of him either.What Obama is doing is showing that you can transend race and get votes,business opportunies ect, ect with the right mind set.Further more he's demostrating that most white folk issues paralell to our issues and he the messenger who happens to be black. He don't have to be on probation to prove he's black. I think Tavis channeling the wrong energy at the wrong subject.
Thank you so much for your intelligent commentary. I am so proud to see our people not be afraid to speak out against what is blaitanly unfair, even if the unjust behavior is coming from someone who has supported us in the past.
Tavis was, and still is as of today's TJM show, way out of line. It is one thing to not support Senator Barack, but it is a whole other thing to attempt to bash and blackmail his efforts. It is suspiciously apparent that Tavis' actions stem from his oversized ego, jeaslousy and hopes for personal gain from promises by the Clinton camp.
From this country's history, we have been shown that a segregated mentality is supported by a foundation rooted in evil. Maybe Senator Barack has not primarily focused on Black issues during his quest for the presidential bid. However, what he has done is brought the theme of true unity to the fore front. The idea of ALL people being treated fairly and given humane opportunities is a wonderful thing. I believe his mission is all inclusive which is a far cry from anything this country has ever seen. Isn't that what the great Dr. Martin Luther King gave his life for?
Forgive me, but who is travis smiley, and what has he done, given the chance to get before the public and speak is all fine and well, but what have you did to help, like have you made sure that no one goes hungrey, did you donate a coat or two, did you try to help the katrina victims,have you ever help on a food line, i mean i am like a lot of other people, i may not can afford to buy your books or even get to see all your shows, but i would remember if i heard your name when a cry goes out for help in a crisis, and i don't remember hearing your or maybe you were the silent majority, but even so, be thankful for what you have and thank god you have it, because you never know what tomorrow may bring, and remember this old saying, can't help don't hinder.
Almost every responder here is getting on Tavis's case, but
HILLARY CLINTON IS CONFIRMED TO BE HERE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OBAMA REFUSES TO DEBATE HER IN WISCONSIN AND NOW HE HASN'T YET AGREED TO THIS EVENT?? WHY SHOULD I VOTE FOR HIM!!!
Wake up black people. Many of us are calling the Clintons racist, but if HIllary can take time to come to this event. BARACK NEEDS TO BE THERE!!!!!!!
HILLARY EVEN HAS THIS EVENT ON HER WEBSITE..NO WONDER SOME BLACKS AND FOLKS OF OTHER RACES STILL SUPPORT HER!!!
I'm sorry my brothers and sisters,
i agree with Tavis! Think,thats all he is saying. Remember the election of Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas. Everybody was on his train, then called him a sellout when he told you what he could do and not do when he was elected into office. My advice to you, that in order for Black America to win this we have to do our homework. Read,uderstand and know why! Thats all!
Thank you for the commentary. This will be the first time since its inception that I will NOT tune in for the State of Black America. I can see what state we are in when we can't get past "blast" or hater-ism. But I'm glad to know where and with who Mr. Smiley stands.
Commentary by TAVIS SMILEY
Senator Barack Obama and the State of the Black Union 2008
Tom Joyner Morning Show
Thursday, February 14, 2008
By now many, if not most of you, have either read or heard about the letter faxed to me by Senator
Barack Obama yesterday to officially inform me that he would not be attending the State of the
Black Union symposium next Saturday, February 23, in New Orleans, live on C-SPAN. The letter
was apparently made public on the Internet by the Obama campaign.
This morning a few thoughts now about the letter, about Senator Obama and for that matter, about
Michelle Obama.
First, I want to thank Senator Obama for his letter, although I regret his decision. I said on Tuesday
and I reiterate today, that I believe that this is a critical miscalculation and a missed opportunity.
Having said that, I also feel that should Senator McCain or Governor Huckabee, like Mr. Obama,
end up denying our invitation to appear at this annual Black think tank, it would also be for them as
well, in the long run, a critical miscalculation and a missed opportunity.
Particularly for Senator John McCain, who appears to now be the presumptive Republican nominee
and who decided, as you recall, not to appear last year before Black America in Baltimore.
Indeed, I personally expressed that sentiment to Senator McCain earlier this week. Don’t think that
in the general election, should he be the nominee, that he ain’t going to get reminded frequently that
he kept passing on opportunities to speak to Black and Brown audiences. That’s pretty much
Political Science 101. That’s going to happen, trust me.
Two. For the record, with regard to this letter and the statements made therein, my office was never
contacted by the Obama campaign offering Michelle Obama as a proxy speaker. It never happened.
No letter. No fax. No e-mail. No phone call. No document whatsoever from the Obama camp to
my office, ever, regarding Michelle Obama. She was never offered, it was never discussed.
Three. While I have great admiration and affection for Michelle Obama, had she been offered to us
I would have respectfully declined. Just as we would have declined had Hillary Clinton offered Bill
Clinton; had John McCain offered Cindy McCain; had Mike Huckabee suggested Janet Huckabee.
By any measure, by any measure, Michelle Obama’s personal story is empowering and inspiring. I
am moved by her personal story, as I have been, since I first met her. From the South side of
Chicago to Princeton, to Harvard Law, it is a quintessential American story of overcoming.
That said, last year at Howard, live on PBS, we spoke to candidates only. And that’s what we intend
to do next Saturday, February 23, in New Orleans, live on C-SPAN, speak to candidates only, with
all due respect.
And speaking of Howard, point number four. When we invited Senator Obama last year to
Howard, with all of the other announced Democratic candidates at the time, so many people, so
many people, said publicly, that Tavis is stacking the deck in Obama’s favor. Black college. Black
book. Black audience. Black journalists. Black moderator. “Smiley is stacking the deck for
Obama,” they said.
The Washington Post Editorial Board said that to me to my face. “Aren’t you stacking the deck for
Mr. Obama?” Now, eight months later, another simple invitation, along with all the other
remaining viable candidates, and now he’s being boxed in by me?
Respectfully, that dog just won’t hunt. Because by that logic, at this point in the campaign, any
gathering of Black thought-leaders, opinion-makers and influencers who invite Senator Obama to
appear on stage at a nationally televised event, that invitation --- in and of itself, given that logic ---
would be tantamount to “boxing him in.”
This was simply an invitation, nothing more. There has not been, there is not now, nor will there
be, any effort on my part to snap on the Obama campaign, or the McCain campaign or the
Huckabee campaign, if they choose not to attend. It was just an invitation to him and every other
candidate. Accept or reject. An invitation, nothing more, nothing less.
I’ve lost count now of how many debates the Democrats have had to address other issues that, in
fact, do matter to us. But I can tell you exactly how many times they’ve gathered to specifically
address our issues. There is no comparison.
Point number five. Senator Obama is on a mission. As he suggested in his letter, his mission is to
become the next President of the United States. And I ain’t mad at him. As I’ve said before, and I’ll
say it again, I revel in his historic run for the White House. As a Black man, I celebrate his past
accomplishments. I celebrate his future aspirations.
Respectfully, I knew Barack Obama long before most of us learned to pronounce his name
correctly. So long ago, in fact, that years ago Barack Obama was working with the kids in my
Foundation, speaking to them about leadership development way back when.
I have no personal animus toward Barack Obama.
To quote that great philosopher, George Wallace, “I love him and there ain’t nothing he can do
about it!” That said, I love Black people, too. And I have a vocation. I have a calling. I have a
purpose. And since this ain’t just about me, you have a purpose too. You have a calling, you have a
vocation as well.
And I would hope, this morning, that at the center of our collective calling, is an unconditional love
for Black people. His job right now is to get elected. Our job is to do our part to ensure that
whoever gets elected will be held accountable to the issues that matter most to Black people.
And in that regard, all that I have ever tried to do, with the media platforms, including this one, that
I have been blessed to have access to, is to attempt to speak a love language, to ask critical
questions, to engage in sober assessment and to counsel wise enthusiasm.
If Barack Obama is your candidate, I ain’t mad at you! If Hillary Clinton is your candidate, I ain’t
mad at you! I am not personally in the endorsement business. My small part is to engage in
Socratic questioning. As a Black person, a member of the media, I’ve said many times on this
program, my job is to ask questions, raise issues, address topics, and profile people that otherwise
wouldn’t get that kind of air play.
Now, as the old folk used to say, “I done spoke my piece.”
Senator Clinton has decided to join us. Senator Obama has decided not to. Senator McCain and
Governor Huckabee, we shall see.
But once again, it has never, ever been about them. It has always been about us. We cannot
confuse candidates with the cause. The cause of suffering Black people who are catching hell every
day.
So, I personally; I can only speak for Tavis, I personally have no intention, no interest in discussing
this matter beyond this commentary no matter what’s said about me. Except to promote the
Symposium, which I’ve done every year for almost 10 years now.
I’m told by the folk in the Lt. Governor’s office in Louisiana that it looks like we will have the
largest gathering of volunteers for a single day next Friday on our Day of Service, since Katrina hit
back in 2005. That’s what matters. Loving and serving everyday Black people.
Our conversation next Saturday promises to be spirited, soulful and inspiring.
Finally this morning, as I always say...today, more than ever...love wins. Love wins. Love wins.
Happy Valentine’s Day!
To hear Tavis’ commentary, please visit www.tavistalks.com
Amen. You are so right on point. I'm really disappointed in Tavis...shame on him. At a time when he should be lifting up a fellow brotha, he's playing into his own self-serving interests.
Unfortunately, for you and a few other bloggers, you simply don't get it. Tavis, has made it his life's mission to empower,educate, and promote issues surrounding the black community. This is not about TAVIS SMILEY! It's about the empowerment, enrichment and education of our own people. Black people! Wake up! If Obama will not take the time to address issues concerning our communities, on our turf than who will? If not now, when? Why do so many blacks think that it's o.k for ANYONE running for the presidency (let alone a black man) NOT address issues concerning our communities? And for the blogger that said Michele Obama could answer the questions in place of Obama. Perhaps she could, but she aint running for office, and Hillary aint sending Bill. When the Covenant of Black America was written it was Black America that made the book go number 1 on the NY best seller list, we embraced the book, we believed the book, and stood firm that whom ever ran for office in the 08 election would be held accountable, we as black people would not allow them to assume our votes, we believed we had a voice. So what happened? We didn't know it was going to be a "black man" running for office. So, because of this we have excused Barack from addressing issues concerning our people? How, and why, have we abandoned that stance? Tavis has been preaching the same message since before the book was released, which is to hold whomever accountable, ask the questions, and raise the issues. Is he now supposed to excuse Obama? How is this hating? Why do we think, and say it's o.k for Obama to wait until he's elected, to address the issues? Why do we think it will all be solved then? Do we really believe that everything will then be fixed? Do we think we are all going to get some sorta "Brotha man hook-up" once he is in office? Who was it that said, if you don't stand for something you will fall for anything? And really, do you honestly believe as you stated that "Obama owes no one"? Any, Black man running for the Presidency of the U.S and is the front runner, owes everyone, particualarly Black America. As far as the State of the Union is concerned, Tavis has held these events for the past 10 years, and always in the month of Feb. why? because it's black history month. He has always announced the confirmation or the decline of those invited. Why now is he NOT supposed to do this? Oh yea, I keep forgetting, because it's Barack, and he's one of us? And that's considered "hating". It is a horribly,unfortuante and missed opportunity for Obama not to attend this venue. The last time I checked Hillary, who has confirmed to attend, is still in the race for her bid for the white house. It seems to me that she could really afford to spend a little more time on her campaign, but has managed to make our issues her concern. So, for all those that believe that Tavis is hating, hating on who? And for what? Tavis has not waivered in his message, he has not spoken one word personally against Obama, he has not attacked him, he simply told the truth, the man aint coming. This is not nor has it ever been about Tavis Smiley. The state of the union, is not a "Tavis Smiley party". It is a platform and an opportunity that has been given once a year to shed light on the inequities, and disenfranchise of Black America. It's not about Tavis! It's about us, it's about Black folks. We all know that Barack is not just running for "Black America" he is running for America, so that means what? Issues involving Black America need not be addressed, right now? Everytime I hear that statement from a black person, I just cringe. Furthermore, so that you are better informed, you mentioned "Tavis understands his business is a business", and "this has done far more for his book sales and power in the community". What you obviously did not know was that, Tavis donated every penny from the proceeds of The Covenant of Black America to Third World Press a black owned company, he personally did not, nor did his company make a dime from those sales. So,now is this really about Tavis Smiley or the enrichment of Black America? And lastly As far as him wanting to be Barack Obama? Naw, I think he'd rather remain who he is, a free black man.
Tavis Smiley wouldn't accept the "First Black President" if Hillary declined. Please.
This is so weird reading this. I was just thinking the same about Tavis. In fact, I have lost a great deal of respect for Tavis as I am starting to feel he has his own agenda. Be that as it may, you are 100% correct with your analysis of Tavis.
Dr. Watkins,
I'm missing something here, and I don't think it's just because I'm white. After reading this and listening to Tavis's call-in to the Tom Joyner show, it appears to me that what's important to Tavis is that IF Obama gets elected, he should not become a big disappointment later, a result which would doubly hurt black Americans and the synergy between black and white Americans down the pike.
Also, imhwo, Tavis and Obama are not rivals or on a collision course, but rather are on parallel paths to serve the country. Through destiny and choice, Obama is in a better position to "transcend race", at least to a typical white perspective, while Tavis is working more from within the historic black community. Each is doing valuable work to help us all get over giving race a political dimension that it shouldn't have. Each in his own way is helping to realize Dr. King's dream. Or am I being naive?
Venezia, Tavis commentaries and the tone in which he has delivered them have not been the language of love and they have been personal. Issues have been addressed, Obama's October visit to Tavis show, and the debate at Howard University. Obama's appearance on Tavis show was the perfect venue for questions. What troubles us is that Tavis has only singled out Obama. Shouldn't his commentaries have included attention to Senator Clinton. PLEASE DON'T forget we have given the Clintons a free ride and we are still doing so. I have never seem Tavis this engaged in a political candidate before and even more surprising is the language coming from Andrew Young. Here we are once again being divided as a people and again from within.
Hi Family,
It was said by a blogger that Justice Clarence Thomas "was elected and we were on his train then, now we called him sellout" First, he was not elected he was nominated president George Herbert Bush and by extension approved by capitol hill, further more black folks were not on his train in fact most were anti Clarence Thomas because of his prior written opinions, but thats niether here nor there.
Moreover Family, the power is with us and with in us not by being anti tavis, anti Obama or anti Hilliary but, by being pro whatever you want as individuals or as a community (Energy flows were Energy goes), i'm pro Obama not anti hilliary, anti Tavis although i disagree with his tactics and true intention. As for Tavis saying he's not in the Endorsing business he already endorse hilliary by his tone and disposition of his commentary perhaps unbeknownst to him and Why i can't figure out for the life of me, because as a matter of fact President Bill Clinton or First Lady Hilliary through my recollection have not done anything for the black community legislatively and had eight years to do so, but i must admit they will accept an invitation to appear (for a fee) to a NAACP,or Urban League dinner as keynote and raise the roof with there speak.... Family Tavis spoke of love and a part of love is honoring the vast differences in our community even though we may not agree and celebrating our diversities,past accomplishments, future accomplishments and future aspirations. I still disapprove of Tavis comments and think it was derived from a negative spirit camouflage as love along with the knowledge that the same access to the whitehouse afforded by hilliary may not be the same with obama if elected even though Tavis will still have access to Obama ear, but maybe not be invited to stay in the re-decorated lincoln room overnight even though it is public housing.
Tavis said the intention of the invitation was for socratic Black issue questioning and if thats the case at this point that should be address at a grassroots to our Congressman,Congresswoman and senators before they are elected because they send the bills to the President. The Groups with the heavy influence operate this way by way of lobbist, this how powerful interest groups operate.
I believe the only reason Hilliary accepted is because her once large constituency in the black community have revolted and this present a oppurtunity for her to gain some cool points. But last but not least we witness a hilliary campaign that was an A+ operation turned to an D- stunt.
love you guys
The reaction of Tavis, Shelia Jackson Lee, Andrew Young, etc to the Sen. Obama signals an end to race and poverty pimps. Those who annoit themselves as the only one's who can communicate and translate Black thought to the wider community. Their days are numbered with the election of Sen. Obama.This event will be the day of liberation for all of Black America, when we begin to think for ourselves, set our own agendas, and yes even select our own leaders.
All of these self appointed leaders will then need to find jobs without riding on the backs of Black folks. So Tavis keep "hating" all the way until we are free of you and your comrades in race baiting for personal profit.
[quote]Similarly, only true love for the black community can lead Tavis Smiley, or anyone else, to give up their own black power to open the gates for someone who might be a bit more effective. I am not sure if Obama is that guy, but a lot of people think he is.
[/quote]
Dr. Watkins:
I pulled the above quote from your commentary because these two points strike at the heart of my personal mission:
Separating notion of what is POPULARLY thought to be what is "in the BEST INTERESTS OF BLACK AMERICA" with what can be EFFECTIVELY PROVEN to be the BEST INTERESTS OF BLACK AMERICA" by empirical evidence sampled on the ground. Thus I ask you to expand your entire focus beyond Barack Obama and instead key upon the POPULAR ASSUMPTIONS made by Black folks in America today.
Today we stand as a network of communities across America with nearly all of the communities where we form the majority within being represented by a political machine at the local level that is now attempting to take over the top of the pyramid - the executive branch - to seal the deal for Black America....or so they say.
Last weekend I was treated to the re-release of "Eyes On The Prize 2". They showed the campaign of Carl Stokes of Cleveland. I was struck by the notion that if I crossed out Stokes and Put "Obama" in and then make it a national campaign rather than a municipal one - the hopes and dreams of the Black folks involved would be nearly identical.
I also have the vantage point of 40 years of history that shows that many of these hopes and dreams as expressed by Black folks in Cleveland have failed to be recognized. Thus the use of your word "EFFECTIVE" struck me as being peculiar. As an Independent who scrutinizes the tendencies of my race of people regarding why we seem stuck where we are - I can't help but notice that we seem more interested in "head count" rather than EFFECTIVENESS as it is demonstrated on the streets of our communities and in the lives of our people as proof that the political activism that so consumes us is bearing the proper fruit.
Why do you ask Tavis Smiley to SUPPORT what turns out to be his 'ideological soul mate" (from my perspective) rather than daring to inspect the EFFECTIVENESS of that which already dominates the Black community near and far?
In my view the Black community needs to decide if we are advocating for more Blacks to be elected or if we are advocating to have our common goals recognized. (Quality schools, Safe Streets, Local Economic Expansion, and Healthy Lifestyles).
It seems to me that the Democrats have grown in power within our communities for the past 40 years more than Black folks have obtained our goals in an ORGANIC fashion as we now have more people of our own choosing governing our communities than ever before.
Thanks to the blogger who posted Tavis' commentary. Yes, Hillary Rodham Clinton, with her misleading ads, accepted the invite because she needs the votes,... by any means necessary.
Tavis sounds like a grown man pouting because Obama will not be able to make it to "HIS" State of the Union event. Is Tavis boiling over with professional jealousy? Barack Obama is running for the President of the USA and addresses many issues that affect the Black community - social economic, education, affordable health care, technology, the future. Is Obama's message coonsistent with the Black Covenant? I think so. I donated to his presidential campaign. Such a donation is a first for me after 50 years.
Dr. Boyce is right on point.
Come on people, do not compare Senator Barack Obama to Clarence Thomas-- 2 distinct qualities.
It is amazing to me that we as a people are quick to turn on those who do not agree or support "the Black candidate", and we are willing to make excuses as to why the "Black cadidate" is justified in whatever he or she does. If Hillary Clinton had not accepted if she were still in the lead,we would be screaming that she was taking us for granted. Now we say that it's fine for Obama because he is trying to become President; I don't buy it. What his refusal says to me is that he does not want to be seen at all Black venue for fear that his white supporters might not understand. Understand that I am no fan of Al Sharpton or Jessie Jackson, but Obama can not ask for their support in the dark and be afraid to be seen on the same stage with them in the daylight. Why are we attacking Tavis? This is not the first time Tavis has called someone on the carpet for not showing up at one of his conferences.Should we not expect the same respect from our Black cadidate as we would from the other candiates? I support Senator Obama in his endeavor to be come President, but I do not support his rejection of Tavis' invitation. He,more than any other candidate should be there.
One of the reasons that Tavis Smiley and his show does well is because he seeks common ground on the respect (and faith) of intellectual scholars unwilling to denigrate others for profit, or for power.
In fact, he has stopped anyone short who is apt to drift into that forbidden territory believing, rightly so, that nothing whatsoever is gained by insinuations of other people's failures, ignorance, or indignities. If he were otherwise, white people would not even watch the show. The Smiley show has never been about degrading white people, nor blacks, nor women. His respect for all persons shows in every show, with every utterance, and if anything, he shows special deference to women and to the elderly, perhaps understanding that if we cannot listen to them, we cannot learn from them.
There need not be pretense on the Smiley Show because it would never work. It has always been about honest dialogue that people can relate to and enjoy, whether from blacks or whites.
It's disturbing, therefore, to hear that Obama announced his campaign hoping to capitalize upon the Smiley charisma given some of the remarks he makes, such as those insinuating that what Hillary doesn't understand is that ...as if he is the person to teach her - because of her apparent ignorance. This goes against the entire philosophy of the Smiley show which depends upon honesty and deference, now showmanship, to discuss and debate.
Obama is a very charismatic speaker but those kinds of derogatory remarks are out of place, and out of line, to Hillary as a woman, and to Hillary as the former First Lady.
It's disturbing that Barak Obama apparently doesn't have the kind of respect for elders that shows a depth of understanding for mankind that illustrate the values that most Americans are familiar with. Perhaps this is due to the vigor of the campaign, or perhaps it is due to bad judgement and arrogance.
Whatever it is, it is in bad taste, and it makes one think that the only person worth debating for Obama is either Bill Clinton or John McCain, and his references have intimated as much.
It's obvious that Obama is a man on a mission, but the mission is of a nature that even he cannot afford to overlook - that whites, as well as blacks, women as well as men, children as well as the elderly deserve the respect as citizens, as the public that would pay his salary if he wins, and that faith, if any, that is earned is as public servant, not ruler.
The campaign is not about what Obama needs; it is about what America needs, and about what America wants. Blacks know that already intuitively.
Blacks know whites, and for whites who know blacks, the tone offered by Obama is not one too often that offers one that shows a respect that should be there. At 46, he's old enough to know that, and it's not always about what he says, but what he doesn't say, how he doesn't act as well as how he does.
I happened onto this page through a link. I am an African American woman but not black, I am brown. My mom is American and my dad is North African. I see both sides of what everyone is saying. I do believe both Barack and Hillary are great candidates. I am personally supporting Hillary. I find Hillary to be qualified as President and a proven leader. I am impressed by Sen Obama but I do have one concern I feel that he capitalizes off referring to Hillary as divisive. I have been to many countries and Hillary Clinton is a true International leader who has stood up for children, women and all people from Bangladeshi to Black Americans. I fear with Obama's message of unity is an empty promise because he doesn't demonstrate leadership against the sexist media who tries to portray Hillary in all sorts of negative ways, he goes along with it and defends it and says I didn't say it. I ask my African American brethren to please push Sen. Obama to denounce sexism as I encourage Hillary to always denounce racism. Thank you for reading my comment.
Black people like all other should free to have their own opinions and voices. We should nor condemn Brother Smiley for having a different view than what the white press has told Black people should have.
If we can not depend on Senator Obama to speak up for now, what makes us think he will stand with us later.
Anonymous, if you are a regular listener of Tavis Smiley commentaries, and it appears that you are. I am quite certain that you aware of the passion, and conviction in which he expresses himself. I do agree that his tone appears to be personal, and that is because it probably is. I believe that he takes this matter personal, as this affects the issues that he has always affectionately represented. Obama, has visited Tavis show, and yes he showed up at Howard with all the other democrats, and of course questions were asked, and answered. However, The State of the Black Union is a platform where think tankers, politicians, and other community leaders gather to discuss those issues specifically concerning African American people. The event draws over 100 million viewers yearly; it has continued to be one of the highest rated shows on C-SPAN. This year's symposium is accurately labeled "Reclaiming our Democracy, Deciding our future". So why would Tavis Smiley as we know him allow Barack to skip out on this one? Do you really think Tavis as we know him, is going to allow the "brotha” to pass unscaved? Because he is a blackman, does this excuse him? If it were not Barack Obama and it were any other democrat black or white seeking our vote, Tavis, as we know him would have made the same comments. And by the way I still have yet to hear, or read any negative comments that were supposedidly spoken by Tavis. I think the media, journalist, disc jockeys, and Tavis Smiley wantabe's have been able to boost their ratings at the expense of Tavis standing on his integrity, not wavering, and continuing to raise awareness, ask the questions, and address the issues of our people, because that's just what he does. Thanks for your direct response.
Give credit where credit is due. Obama has led his campaign organization very well. Hillary led her campaign very well also up to Feb. 5th. She thought it was in the bag (A Shocker). This is a historic moment. I am a Black single Woman with children pulling for Obama. The republican party, media, and talk radio have been calling Hillary devisive for years, so let's not put that on Obama.
Did you ever think in your lifetime that a white woman or a Black man would have a real chance of becoming President of the USA. It is time for a change. Rather than bicker we should be celebrating! Boundaries have been broken no matter who wins. Think about it, OUR FUTURE...
This is way bigger than black on black turf war, because this historic event is a win-win moment with limitless outlook for us and our children.
Yes Tavis event has interesting and thoughtful dialogue, but the man is busy. I ask again, is Obama and his campaign Issues outlined on his web page in alignment wit the Black Covenant? So, Where's the understanding for the Senator who lives and works in Chicago running for da Prez? Let's put our ego aside and focus on strategies for the future!
== Vote ==
Does it make one wrong to disagree with another, until facts are presented? Why do you take sides before searching out the truth? Why is it so easy for you to vote for someone who runs for office, just because they are black? Do you check their backgrounds before you take sides? Do you really read whats going on in the black community? Do you really understand it? Do you even know why?
To the bloggers that answered me about Justice Thomas! Look up the word nominate. We did'nt but they did! Missed the point. All blacks who decide to become black leaders must be held accountable to the black community. Every other race thats in office addresses their kind at one time or another. Is it wrong for ours to do that? Yes, Tavis is harder on Senator Obama than Senator Clinton, on the issues that apply to us. Were we not raised to be that way about us from us? Are we not taught by our parents to expect more from ourselves than the other races do? Are we not taught to represent our kind?
I'm not here to take sides,
but to send a message to my brothers on something that we don't do enough of. Again, i say to you! READ, UNDERSTAND and KNOW WHY!!!!!!!
I have just finished reading most of the Posts on this subject. Let me say I am so proud of Y'all. The Posts are in large measure, reasoned and articulate. This NEW AMERICAN MAJORITY being forged out of the OBAMA Campaign for President is going to grow. It's growth is necessary to fullfil the promise of a Democracy. The dramatic increase in participation in our Government is a remarkable phenomenon. People all across the Country are finding their "Voice".
Which brings me to a point, What is it we have here, is it a Democracy or a Republic? Mr. Bush represents not just the Republican party, but the notion of a Republic, where his will is divorced from the will of the people who elected him. Kind of like the SuperDelegate thing. Could we talk about that?
finally,
some profound conversation, in our community. i believe mr.smiley has helped the black community tremenduously, however he and others are not being honest with their debate about obama. the fact still remains that, many in our community, innitialy did not support obama due to two miscaculations. firts, he was negated for his lack of approachment to some civil rights issues, but after conversations with one brilliant scholar name, mr. west bridge that gap, for civil rights should not be synonymous only with african american. second, we all, including i assumed white voters simply would not vote for a black president, now he has proven both myth and miscaculations wrong in the word of martin lawrence "what the problem is". join the train
For some time I have been apprehensive about Tavis Smiley.I remember when I first saw him back in 1995 on NPR and PBS he wrote a book passionately talking about "The New Left".I thought back then that this man was at odds with the beliefs of the African-American community.We are a neutral people on the whole when it comes to politics.We only vote for Democrats because of our of fear of the right wing Republicans.These Black democrats have been exposed a lackeys of the Clintons.This election is about us freeing ourselves from people who politically exploit us.We have had it with the Smileys,Sharptons,Lewis's ect who keep drinking the Clinton kool aid.A new day is dawning and Obama is helping free us.
Tavis is right for holding everybody's feet to the fire...including Senator Obama's.
I agree totally with your commentary but I do have a question: Who appointed Tavis Smiley the GREAT SPOKESMAN FOR BLACK AMERICA? Tavis is just a talker, a self promoter, and now I think he is an egotistical idiot - a sham. I will admit that he talks a good game, but walking the walk. Did Tavis go to the March in Jena, LA. We have supported you by buying your books, paying to go to your lectures, and rooting for you when you were fired from BET. So Tavis stick to your sellout PBS gig.
I agree completely that you cannot be somebody unless you convince somebody that you are somebody. I’ll say you are as blind as Ray Charles on this one. Does anyone really think the Hillary will extend all that much courtesy to us (Black people), if she wins with all the experience she claims to has, which her Presidency will amount to being a proxy for Bill - MORE OF THE SAME and a continuation of the problem. The Clintons had 8 years and it is time for a CHANGE… They are talented in lies and deception of which we have bought. I am educated as well and I would never vote for a team that will do anything to win. Remember this:
1. Rwanda 1994
2. Nafta
3. Welfare reform
4. Monica
Lastly, after he disrespected us in South Carolina, he his is really one of us because pulled a “N_WORD” move much is the way Tavis is doing now. I say that because it seems as if they are playing the crab in the basket game. So let Tavis Smiley & Hilary Clinton play all of the games and traditional tricks they want. Sure Hillary is showing up, you are paying for the free publicity. Don’t you see Tavis that the Clintons are using you!
If someone like Mr. Obama is seated at the table, let alone the head of the table, can be more of a benefit to Black People than sitting with Smiley. The last time I checked, what came out of this conference last year paled in comparison to the opportunity before us. Tavis I recognize that the devil tempts us all and I will pray for you to see the light as God's hand is in the works here... Sen. Obama is being guided correctly. Let us all pray and trust that the Holy Spirit continue to guide him. Tavis you are an embarrassment and it is time for us to let you go and stop acting like the last voice of Black America.
What is more important being at the State of the Black Union or delivering the State of the Union? Rest assured I will now question anything that Smiley says, if I listen at all, because more than likely I will be changing the station when his is schedule on the TJMS, if not switching to Steve Harvey from now on.
I am confused. Obama says his campaign is not about race, and was upset because Bill Clinton, according to Obama, implied he was the "Black Candidate", as if this was a slur.
But from what I see the reality is that Obama IS a Black or AA man, and HE is making this about race, not issues.
I am a Democrat, and I am upset about the tone of this election. John Lewis, my Congressman, recently was subjected to RO_BO calls from people threatening him if he did not pledge to support Obama at the convention. He gave in to this, a man who faced beatings and jail, caved in to this. Clinton did not change her positions, and when I last saw him at the GEORGIA J/J dinner, he was secure in HIS position of supporting Clinton.
Is this a campaign about Black/White, or about GOP/Dem?
Why is Obama so angry about being identified as a BLACK man? He